Does stirring increase the initial rate of oxygen uptake?
Students used equal masses of germinating seeds, kept at the same temperature. They measured oxygen uptake per gram in stirred and unstirred chambers. Each result below comes from a different batch of seeds. All unstirred batches came from one seed packet, and all stirred batches came from a different packet.
| Batch | Unstirred | Stirred |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 3.2 | 4.2 |
| 2 | 3.8 | 4.9 |
| 3 | 4.4 | 3.8 |
- Compare the group means and comment on the individual measurements.
- Explain why these results are insufficient to attribute the difference to stirring.
- Propose a better allocation of seeds and a control for changes due to the apparatus.
Compare with a reasoned answer
The mean is 3.80 without stirring and 4.30 with stirring. The ranges overlap and there are only three independent batches per treatment. Packet and treatment are confounded, so different germination or respiration between packets could explain some of the difference. Divide seeds from each packet between both conditions, randomly allocating comparable batches. Repeat with several independent packets, and run seed-free chambers in both conditions to detect changes in oxygen readings due to the apparatus or stirring alone.